Архив метки: World Heritage Watch

World Heritage Watch Report 2024: Can UNESCO Still Protect the World Heritage?

2024.06 WHW Report 2024 cover pageOn June 1, 2024, World Heritage Watch a non-governmental organization that closely monitors the condition of natural and cultural sites included in the World Heritage List and the Tentative List, announced the release of the next report (1).

«Today, the non-governmental organization World Heritage Watch presents its tenth annual report on threats to UNESCO World Heritage Sites. It contains 55 contributions from all continents on cultural monuments, historic city centers, cultural landscapes and nature reserves, including several with indigenous populations.

Every year, the World Heritage Watch Report highlights the state of humanity’s common heritage. It is submitted to the UNESCO World Heritage Centre and the Member States of the International Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Natural and Cultural Heritage (“World Heritage Convention”) to help them make a more comprehensive assessment of the threats and take more appropriate decisions to address them».

Global trends are not encouraging. In many countries, «local communities have been waiting for years for more decisive action from the UNESCO World Heritage Committee, for example in Stonehenge, Diyarbakir, St. Petersburg and the Acropolis of Athens. Frustration is growing that this body, made up of diplomats, gives priority to political interests rather than to the protection of heritage. In Venice, at Lake Ohrid, but also on the Upper Middle Rhine Valley, people have almost lost hope that the UNESCO World Heritage Convention can deliver on its promise to protect the sites under their tutelage».

There is also positive news. «Last year, President Biden declared nearly 1 million acres (404,685.642 ha) adjacent to Grand Canyon National Park a national monument, not only prohibiting further uranium mining, but also protecting sacred sites of several indigenous nations».

2023.10.06 Аксай 4472Two publications in the report are dedicated to Kazakhstan. The Ecological Society Green Salvation prepared the material «Legal obstacles to the implementation of the World Heritage Convention in the Republic of Kazakhstan». It highlights the situation in the Ile-Alatau National Park, which was included in the Tentative List for inscription on the World Heritage List back in 2002. Another material, «Imminent threats to the Western Tien Shan in Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan», talks about threats to the transboundary World Heritage site The Western Tien Shan, which was inscribed on the World Heritage List in 2016.

The main threats to World Heritage sites in Kazakhstan remain the same. This is the inconsistency of many norms of national legislation with the norms of the Convention, poor implementation of its requirements by government and business structures, economic development of specially protected natural areas, overtourism, and depletion of water resources, urbanization, and ineffective management.

We invite interested readers to familiarize themselves with the important and informative materials of the report.

_______________________

1. WHW – https://world-heritage-watch.org/.

Ile-Alatau National Park is included in the World Heritage Watch Report 2021

AH2A6177sWorld Heritage Watch (WHW – https://world-heritage-watch.org/ ) is the first NGO focusing exclusively on World Heritage sites, both cultural and natural, and both inscribed and listed tentatively. The WHW network includes more than 180 groups and individuals from different parts of the world. World Heritage Watch task is to work with UNESCO and its Advisory Bodies, and to complement their efforts for the effective implementation of the World Heritage Convention and the safeguarding of World Heritage Sites.

Why did the creators of the organization decide to take up such a difficult task? They explain this as follows: «But more and more world heritage sites are threatened by development pressure, mass tourism, war, resource depletion, urbanization, climate change and investor projects, but also by neglect and mismanagement. UNESCO alone is powerless; it can only warn governments».

One of the most important forms of work of WHW is the collection of information from independent sources, its dissemination and provision to the governing bodies of the Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. This allows the world community to more reasonably judge the condition of objects and make informed decisions.

WHW recently released its next 2021 results report (https://world-heritage-watch.org/content/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/WHW-Report-2021.pdf). This year’s World Heritage Watch Report has 49 contributions, almost 20% more than last year’s.

One material prepared by the Ecological Society «Green Salvation» is dedicated to the Ile-Alatau National Park, included in the tentative list for inclusion in the World Heritage List from Kazakhstan, back in 2002! Almost all of the above threats currently hang over the territory of the national park: development pressure, mass tourism, depletion of water resources, urbanization, climate change, investment projects, and poor management.

In general, there is a lack of understanding of the role and importance of protected areas at all levels of society, from ordinary people to officials, including the highest level.

During 2019 and 2020, the Ecological Society «Green Salvation» has repeatedly drawn the attention of the Committee for Forestry and Wildlife, which subordinates national parks, and other authorized state bodies to the need to ensure the rule of law and strict compliance with international agreements.

The Ecological Society «Green Salvation» believes that it is necessary to introduce the following fundamental changes in the legislation and in the management of protected areas:

  1. Bring the environmental legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan in line with the requirements of international conventions.
  2. To remove all third-party (outside) land owners from the borders of protected areas of republican significance.
  3. Completely prohibit the transfer of protected areas from the category of “land of protected areas” to the category of “reserve land.”
  4. To prohibit capital construction in reserves and national parks, except for what is necessary for the functioning of their administrations.
  5. To prohibit the provision of land plots of national parks for lease, with the exception of the construction of strategic facilities.
  6. Local authorities of some administrative territories intervene in the conservation activities of national parks located in these territories. It is necessary to amend the law on protected areas to prohibit such interference.

 

For details, see the report p.190

 

Ile Alatau National Park is included in the World Heritage Watch Report 2020

Страницы из WHW-Report-2020World Heritage Watch (WHW – https://world-heritage-watch.org/) is the first NGO focusing exclusively on World Heritage sites, both cultural and natural, and both inscribed and listed tentatively. The WHW network includes more than 150 groups from different parts of the world. World Heritage Watch task is to work with UNESCO and its Advisory Bodies, and to complement their efforts for the effective implementation of the World Heritage Convention and the safeguarding of World Heritage Sites.

Why did the creators of the organization decide to take up such a difficult task? They explain this as follows: «But more and more world heritage sites are threatened by development pressure, mass tourism, war, resource depletion, urbanization, climate change and investor projects, but also by neglect and mismanagement. UNESCO alone is powerless; it can only warn governments».

One of the most important forms of work of WHW is the collection of information from independent sources, its dissemination and provision to the governing bodies of the Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage. This allows the world community to more reasonably judge the condition of objects and make informed decisions.

WHW recently released its next 2019 results report (https://world-heritage-watch.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/WHW-Report-2020.pdf). Representatives of civil society participated in its preparation, which provided information on 42 world heritage sites of various types.

One material prepared by the Ecological Society «Green Salvation» is dedicated to the Ile-Alatau National Park, included in the tentative list for inclusion in the World Heritage List from Kazakhstan, back in 2002! Almost all of the above threats currently hang over the territory of the national park: development pressure, mass tourism, depletion of water resources, urbanization, climate change, investment projects, and poor management. This year, an unprecedented onslaught of commercial structures (tenants) on the territory of Ile-Alatau National Park began. A threat loomed over the Altyn-Emel National Park, which was included in the tentative list for inclusion in the World Heritage List in 2002.

The public of Kazakhstan sent an open appeal to the president, government and deputies of the parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan in order to put an end to the destructive activities of business structures in the territories of national parks.